Formaggio's Pie Shack

Formaggio's Pie Shack, London 1600 Highbury Ave N - London

Italian
• Pizza
• Canadian
• Sit down

84/100
Recommended by 2 people
Give a rating

What's your favorite Formaggio's Pie Shack's dish?

Ratings and reviews

84
/100
Based on 1486 ratings and reviews
Updated

The menu of Formaggio's Pie Shack suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of Formaggio's Pie Shack

TA

Trip
Last update on 07/06/2023
4,5
137 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 12/01/2024
4,5
898 Reviews
Foursquare
Foursquare
Last update on 09/08/2023
3,5
8 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 09/08/2023
4,0
237 Reviews
Zomato
Zomato
Last update on 28/12/2022
4,6
88 Reviews

DD

Doordash
Last update on 09/08/2023
4,0
44 Reviews

UE

Uber eats
Last update on 12/01/2021
4,3
14 Reviews

Reviews

Zomato
Jack O'donnel
+5
Ordered delivery from Formaggio’s as a first time customer. Indicated right away on the order that they were busy and delivery time would be a little longer which I appreciated knowing ahead of time and before order placed. Ordered there famous deep dish which I had heard so much about. The pizza isn’t cheap, but I believe you get what you pay for. This was by far, the BEST pizza we have eaten. All great and fresh ingredients and well put together. Amazing crust!! The delivery ended up coming in at the original time which was great also. Will definitely order again. You have a niche Formaggio’s, don’t change a thing!!
Sep 18, 2018
Zomato
Herb
+4
This is an amazing and unique pizza definitely worth a try. We had a hot sausage, pepperoni and bacon that was amazing. Had 2 larges split into 2 types and it wasn't cheap but it was really good. I would definitely go back in a heartbeat.
Sep 08, 2018
Zomato
Rashi Kansal
+4
Formaggios has amazing deep dish pizza. The deep dish pizza isnt cheap but well worth the price. The deep dish pie is stuffed with toppings and cheese. The large is like a 5 pound pizza. It will feed several people. The pizza has a crazy amount of cheese on it. Great pizza. You have to try it.
Aug 24, 2018
Zomato
Diksha Khurana
+4
I have been staying in London for some extended duration due to medical treatments and have been craving a really good authentic pizza that has it all, especially a great tasting sauce and cheese. Well, we went through the rankings and stumbled on this place....I would drive hours just for the pizza. THE BEST DEEP DISH I HAVE EVER HAD anywhere. The toppings are incredible, the the cheese combo. You will never leave hungry thats for sure. The guy making the pizza really is an expert at this and knows how to hit it out the park....super nice guy too and server was wonderful.
Aug 01, 2018
Zomato
Fine Diner
+4
The restaurant is located next to Billy T's in a small plaza in North London. The kitchen is behind the order desk so the entire creative process is transparent. Staff was pleasant and seemed to be happy working there.
They do have a room that is open for eat in several days a week.

First of all if you don't like a lot of cheese and don't understand Italian be wary of this place. Formaggio is Italian for cheese and they use plenty. Also don't go here if you are looking for an ordinary pizza or do not want to spend more than a franchise charges. Pizzas here are unique and high priced compared to frozen or franchise.
We ordered for pick up the medium deep dish with mushrooms, pepperoni, red peppers, black olives and packed with their home made sweet sauce.
It lived up to the many opinions on this site.
The only complaint we had was not the fault of Formaggio's as I was there to pick it up when it came out of the oven. It cooled off by the 15 minutes it took to get home and cheese hardened a bit on top. Suggest eating in for a hot pizza. Would have no problem returning and ordering one of their regular pizzas.
Apr 09, 2016
Zomato
Alisha Ding
+4
Oh. My. Goodness. The deep dish pizza here shouldn't really be called pizza. There's just so much to it, they don't skimp on the toppings and their original sauce is just great. But the cheese. There's more cheese than crust and toppings. There's so much cheese that you'd have a cheese pull the length of an Olympic swimming pool. It's almost too much. Almost. If you haven't tried the deep dish here then order now before they stop delivering to your area!
Nov 30, 2015
Zomato
Dawebguy2000
+4.5
Had a 3 item large deep dish. $38. It was awesome but more like a Panzerotti on its side than pizza. Thick heavy cheese which I love so be prepared for the price and a thick slice of heaven!
Oct 29, 2015
Zomato
Skochaqui
+4.5
While a little pricey, this is undoubtedly the best pizza that London has to offer. For all you pizza lovers out there, Fromaggio's is a must try.
Jun 21, 2015
Zomato
Ashley
+4.5
I'm glad I finally bucked up and tried this place . I had a deep dish medium with pepperoni mushroom and bacon. It was definitely good - but I wouldn't pay 40$ for a pizza again ( delivery and tip included in that ). It wasn't overwhelming great for me . I honestly felt silly spending that much but I heard heard nothing but good things about the deep dish . I will definitely order from them again- just not something so expensive .
May 21, 2015
Zomato
Tay
+4.5
Awesome Pizza!. My new favourite Pizza place! The pizza is amazing and I love the garlic bread. Will be back frequently!
Apr 25, 2014
5
Melissa Reis
+5
We tried her on our pizza tour! We are so glad we did! Amazing pizza...both deep dish and thin crust. Out of 5 stars this is how we feel about the pizza. Crust How did it taste and was it easy to wrangle? 4.5 both Sauce How likely would you be to eat this with a spoon? 4.5 Cheese Was there too much or too little cheese? Was it gross when it cooled down? 5 Toppings Ratio Was there enough of everything? Was anything too overpowering? 5 Value Is this a pizza you could afford to make a habit? 3.5 Charisma This is how all of the above comes together, and can include the restaurant and ambiance. 5 Total Rating How does this pizza compare to my favourite in the world? 4.5 My daughter and husband also tried the stuffed pickles and loved them.
4
Ziyad
+4
Great place with fair pricings and deals. Heard so much about the deep dish which was good. Will definitely come back to try other dishes besides the pizza.
5
Erin Dawe
+5
Updated Review: We just had dine in dinner and it was phenomenal! We started with the stuffed mushroom caps and cheesy garlic bread and it was amazing. The garlic bread was super cheesy and the mushroom caps were stuffed full! My husband and I had panzerottis, they were twice the size of my hand and stuffed full of toppings and cheese. My mom had the penne pasta and the portion was big and full of toppings. And my dad had the spicy Sammy, it was huge and the perfect amount of spicy. I’ll definitely be back, there are so many more menu items I want to try!
5
Jeremy Kwiecien
+5
We ordered deep dish pizzas around 6 pm on a Thursday. The pies were ready when expected. They were hot and delicious. I've never had deep dish pizza from anywhere else to compare, but the ones from Formaggios were very good. While the food was take out, waiting in the restaurant it had a lively and friendly atmosphere. The staff I dealt with were very pleasant.
5
C Ridley
+5
Wow is all I can say You will not be disappointed My daughter also had this as part of her make a wish when we lived in London This is one place we surely miss but highly recommend!
5
Tiffany Hart
+5
Hands down one of the best pizzas we have ever had. Let me preface with with the fact that this isn’t your “traditional” deep dish pizza nor is it something you want to get if you’re not literally obsessed with cheese. Now that said. Don’t think of going hear & leaving a bad review because they use too much cheese or it’s “not a real deep dish”. Do your research and make sure it’s something you’ll like before going there. Moving along. We drive over an hour and half to get this pizza & it’s worth every bit of hassle. The toppings, the sauce, side dipping sauces are all amazing. I highly recommend their garlic ranch & chipotle mayo for dipping. The nachos are a bit pricey as they usually are at most places. But here they are totally worth it. They are COVERED from corner to corner will toppings and cheese! They don’t hold back at all! Everything on their menu is great. But you have to experience the deep dish at least once!
5
Mashruk “Finn” Kabir
+5
EZ 9/10 deep dish pizza. Super crunchy crust, zesty sauce and ample amount of cheese. Excellent.
5
Shannon McIntyre
+5
My goodness, I went 3 weeks ago and I still can’t stop thinking about the deep dish pizza or the garlic bread. Sooooooo goood!!!!
5
Jason Cousins
+5
Great atmosphere and experience, deep dish pizza is really good and filling!
5
Matthew Le Sage
+5
Worth the drive!!! I had the stuffed deep dish pizza that was cooked to perfection, cheese browned on top and the crust great tasting while holding together the HUGE amount of cheese and toppings. The service was excellent and friendly. I live over an hour away and will be making trek again.

Description

Timetable

Monday:
04:00 PM - 08:30 PM
Tuesday:
11:00 AM - 08:30 PM
Wednesday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday:
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:
12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday:
12:00 PM - 08:00 PM

Order online with

Zomato
Zomato

DD

Doordash

Book a table with

Zomato
Zomato

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Foursquare
Foursquare
Facebook
Facebook
Zomato
Zomato

UE

Uber eats

Info

Compare the best restaurants near Formaggio's Pie Shack

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

Formaggio's Pie Shack

85 4.5 4 4.5
Zen'Za Pizzeria 92 4.8 4 5
David's Bistro 89 4.8 4.7 4.5
Plant Matter Kitchen 90 4.6 4.5 4.5
Tamarine by Quynh Nhi 91 4.5 4.5
Thaifoon Restaurant 91 4.5 4.8 4.5
Tuscanos Pizzeria & Bistro 87 4.5 4 4.5
Abruzzi 84 4.5 4 4.5

The Chef reccomend

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 84 based on 1486 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 519-457-2233

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1