The best Restaurants in Port Carling ranking of May 2025
22 restaurant menus in Port Carling, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Service is great, patio is awesome and the menu and food is fantastic. Slightly pricey but everything else makes it worth..."
Ryan O'Hallarn
"Came all the way from Huntsville after work to eat here. Definitely recommend the steak. Friendly waitresses and great food..."
Andrew Tyler Mondragon
"Love this place. Great food, great service and the outdoor patio on the water is so amazing. We travel 4hrs to go at least once a..."
Johanne Blais
"Always love going to Turtle Jacks when I am in Port Carling. Tops off the shopping nicely! Swift service with lots of cheery and polite..."
Kelly Jane Weedon
"Sunny days at turtle jacks on the patio are always fantastic. Great food and..."
Jessica Lynda
"Awesome staff and amazing food! I love meeting up at Turtle Jacks and coming in off the water. It is a fantastic location in the heart of..."
Laurie Trosino Hulse
"Had a amazing time here and the food was only topped by the friendly service they..."
Tom Miller
"Nice staff and yummy food. Have always had a good experience here! A little pricey but that’s somewhat expected! Would..."
Aleisha Brenneman
"Came on a busy Friday afternoon and had to wait about 40 minutes for a table. The hostesses taking our reservations were super nice and friendly. I..."
Le Yen Lam
"Excellent Patio, service and food! It’s very rare to find a great place to eat. The four of us all had something different and we were not..."
Elizabeth Manarin
"Great location, great atmosphere. Love that they are pet friendly. Service was good-they were super busy and it was really hot, so that may have..."
Daniela Larosa
"We have been here several times. Beautiful patio overlooking the water. Food is great and big portions too. The service there is excellent! Very..."
John P
"Great place! Great view! Great food! Amazing customer service. Must visit spot in Muskoka. Tried the steak and chicken rolls. Recommended one. Shanon..."
"Noticed this cute patio setting that overlooked a gorgeous view to the lake. Staff is super friendly and accommodating to our request to sit out on..."
Mi ShoppingBag
"Great service! Our server was awesome and very accommodating. Food was fresh and superb. We ordered the mussels and the shrimp tacos! Delicious..."
Rena Scitures
"Made a last minute reservation on a Saturday night and got in. Were seated quickly at a lovely table overlooking the water and served efficiently...."
Shira Cwang
"Excellent perfectly cooked meals and amazing service! Very tasty! Awesome large patio with a view of the water and..."
Courtney Fuller
"First time visit, good meal, fantastic views of the river in full flood, very impressive. We had the hamburger which was tasty and savoury, but the..."
Nick Ryeland
"First time out to eat in three months, due to isolation. We were celebrating an anniversary and heard good things. Great food, amazing atmosphere and..."
J
"This spot is great for a fine dining in flavor with a comfortable and cozy environment. The service was great and it is located right on the water...."
Teela Woosen
"Great service, good food but the restaurant has become very expensive now. 2021 was realistic pricing, but a 2022 lunch for 3 people @ $270.00 is..."
"Everything is perfect.food is fantastic,staff are super friendly and helpful ,rooms are so comfy and roomy..on site spa, gym,lounge and..."
Kim Sproule
"This absolutely beautiful resort is like walking into an episode of dirty dancing.Everything about this resort was food for the soul from the..."
Gayle Somerville
"We attended the Mother’s Day lunch and it was fantastic. It’s a beautiful lake side setting and tremendous staff! The food was really great...."
Suzanne Keen
"We attended a beautiful wedding here. Venue and accomodations were great and I cannot say enough good about the food and beverage staff in..."
Jennifer Marie
"When I take a right to turn into the resort I have a permanent smile on my face, this place is a hidden jewel!!! When I went to check in the lady..."
Jacqueline King
"We hosted our wedding here in October and it was perfect! Sherwood was absolutely beautiful with the most friendly and accommodating staff we could..."
Kim Janssen
"I deliver cakes to the Sherwood Inn for events - the staff is extremely friendly and VERY helpful. The inside has a beautiful rustic feel, that..."
Jocelyn Renwick-Stokes
"Perfection on Lake Joseph! Surprise engagement!! Amazing food, beautiful lake views, great service and especially enjoyed Josh taking care of us for..."
Kelli Cowan
"Loved everything about this Inn... the staff were friendly and helpful, the room was large, warm, clean and comfortable, the food was fantastic, the..."
James Positano
"My boyfriend and i enjoyed our time spent at the resort. All of the staff that we engaged with were so friendly and really did everything they could..."
Tracy Hollingshead
"We loved everything about Sherwood Inn. The property is beautiful . The staff can't do enough for you. So helpful and polite. The food was amazing!..."
Sherri MacDermid
"We were only there for one night, but totally loved it. The food was fabulous, and the Caesars.... awesome �!! Went cross-country skiing.. only..."
Rod Johnston
"We just returned from a truly magical time at Sherwood Inn, ringing in our 1st New Year's together. The scenery was beautiful and peaceful.....the..."
"The sandwiches here are absolutely incredible. An easy choice for coffee or lunch in Port Carling. One of my favourite..."
Alex Sweatman
"What amazing sandwiches these guys make!! A very good breakfast or lunch option when you are in the area. Highly..."
Sumit Narula
"Easily the best sandwiches my wife and I have eaten in a long time. I had the Montreal smoked brisket, she had the roasted chicken. The coffee is..."
Pat Brunet
"Ordered the breakfast sandwich and lox sandwich and both were delicious - we came back again another day to get the same! Regular latte was good but..."
Bige Baby
"Best sandwich shop in Muskoka, hands down! The schnitzel is a favourite amongst my workplace, but all options on the menu are flavourful and..."
Kristy Majoran
"Very cute & friendly spot right in the core. VEGAN FRIENDLY COFFEE OPTIONS..."
Nirvana Vie
"Hands down the BEST take out in Muskoka. I have been going for the last two years and have never been disappointed. Cafe drinks are well made, food..."
Audrey Harrison
"New cafe serving a full coffee menu and wide selection for sandwiches and baked..."
"The most beautiful Tim Hortons I have ever seen. The local decor with the canoe, large fireplace & raw wooden floors gives it an authentic vibe. The..."
Ravika
"February 2017
Newly opened in November 2016
Nice Muskoka theme with warm gas..."
Al Jason
"Great place. Easily accessible. Lots of parking spots and drive-thru options..."
Abhijith A
"Great service inside and out! Fast Drive Thru!
Beautiful location and clean!
Lots of Parking and easy to get in and out of
Worth the drive for your..."
Gerald McFall
"Thrilled that we now have this very appealing Tim Horton's in Port Carling. It definitely improves the whole area. The staff were cordial and the ..."
Lou Ann Ballard
"This establishment reflects Muskoka with the stunning stonework and gas fireplace. Very pleasant atmosphere indeed. The staff are friendly and..."
Anita Taylor
"Best Tims ever! Iced coffees are perfect every time, staff is friendly, hours are very good considering the location is seasonal to many cottagers...."
Tee Witzel
"This Timmy is actually a nice place to go to. It looks very Muskoka on the inside and invites for a little stay. It has a Cafe kind of feel, which..."
Christin Adree
"Best looking Tim Horton's I have seen! Great choices, great staff! Bad parking - stones look nice but covered in snow cant see them, and worse that..."
B
"The best bagel i've ever had was from this Tim Horton's. It wasnt dry and stale like they can be at other locations. And I know my bagels. The..."
matt fitz
"This Tim Hortons location is excellent and most importantly, NOT haunted. Very friendly staff, no ghosts, and interesting and unique decor. As with..."
Deryck Lafortune
"This is the most beautiful Tim Hortons I've been in. Very Cottage like. it's a cozy place to actually stay and enjoy a coffee, And if the staff runs..."
kayton zarhloul
"Definitely the nicest Tims I have ever been in. The food/Coffee is amazing as always and the service was first class. So happy we finally have the..."
"Delicious ice cream in the area!
Excellent customer service.
Patio is has a beautiful view to enjoy the town and lake view.
Totally recommend based..."
Palwasha
"Top notch traditional ice cream parlour serving an extensive list of flavours from Kawartha Dairy with friendly and efficient staff. A summer cottage..."
Mike McCauley
"Good icecream, and good customer service! Lots of options, a great place! Would..."
Aleisha Brenneman
"Nice ice cream joint by Kawartha. We tried 2-3 different flavors and liked it. Totally recommend it you are around muskoka..."
Rohit Kumar
"Hot day! Wonderful place to cool off with some yummy ice..."
Erin McEwen-Ryeland
"Love their frozen yogurt, but wish they had multiple machines as the line up for yogurt can get pretty crazy during peek summer days. I always feel..."
"I walked into this location at 815pm on Sunday night. I had been told they close at 9pm. I started placing my order and casually asked "is it true..."
Anna De Carolis
"Always a good Sub.
Clean, good staff but it’s busy during lunch so get there just before the lines..."
"Unexpected visit to Richwell's became the highlight of a week in Muskoka. Great "fine-dining near the cottage" location and mouthwatering menu. Kudos..."
Matthew Gibbins
"Wonderful dining experience. Outstanding food and friendly, knowledgable staff (thanks Leanne) make this a must if you are in Port Carling. Looking..."
Susan Appleton
"The food was delicious as always. It was the perfect temperature to eat. We will be..."
Karen Chamberlain
"The best restaurant in Muskoka! The prime rib is superb. Make sure you save room for..."
Pam Steeves
"Wonderful meal, superb service. If you are near Port Carling this restaurant needs to be number one on your places to..."
Maureenand Scott Morris
"Excellent food and service made my mom's birthday dinner very..."
Brenda Frech Kurtz
"We ordered from Richwell's during the covid lockdown - we were glad to see them doing their best to continue operating at such a difficult time for..."
Tom
"We were here 10 years ago for our wedding rehearsal dinner. It was excellent then and with same chef at the helm, this place is still a Muskoka MUST..."
Tyson Eidt
"We had a wonderful experience at Richwell's. The staff was very welcoming and friendly from the moment we arrived, and the service was superb!..."
Liza Chowdhury
"Our group of 6 had an excellent dinner there. Risotto balls, duck salad, shrimp appetizer, for mains had artic char, lobster pasta dish, chicken..."
Shelley Mikolainis
"We picked this restaurant to celebrate our 41 anniversary not realizing we had been there five years ago on another weekend in Muskoka. The service..."
Bill Helmer
"Great food, outstanding service and went above and beyond to make us feel safe during covid! So glad we chose this restaurant to celebrate my..."
Michelle Lekk
"Always amazing meals at Richwell’s. It is one of the best restaurants in Muskoka. The food is terrific and I have only had great experiences here...."
"Very good ice cream and an amazing view. They don't carry the vegan ice cream here but not a huge deal for me. A little pricey for a kid's cone..."
Lisa McMahon
"Soft serve ice cream topped to the max. Great treat and good size servings but not cheap. Nice outdoor patio overlooking the water to enjoy while you..."
Mike McCauley
"This place is right on the water and affords some amazing and peaceful views while enjoying your ice cream. Very inventive creations and flavour..."
Carsten
"This place is absolutely fabulous! I had the cookies and cream, and got way more then I expected (it was an unholy amount *badum tss*) but that was..."
Adam Stein
"Popsicles had melted slightly so we got a free one! Incredible flavours and beautiful..."
Carolyn Tomkins
"Love this place! Small and a little hard to find (on the waterfront upstairs), but their ice cream is great! Maybe slightly expensive depending on..."
Michael Nokes (Holiday)
"Great ice cream, great customer service. Super cute..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes