TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in Hamilton - Updated November 2024

Chicago Style Pizza Shack

85/100 (3389 ratings)

Restaurants

Vegetarian Friendly

Canadian

Pizza

Italian

Canadian

Pizza

Italian

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

Dinner

After-hours

Alfredo

Tiramisu

Meatballs

Lasagne

Chicken Parmesan

Deep dish pizza

Beef

Eggplant

Bruschette

Pasta

Pesto

Salad

Roast Beef

Sit down

Canadian

Pizza

Italian

Serves Alcohol

Highchairs Available

Accepts Credit Cards

Delivery

Takeout

Seating

Table Service

After-hours

Dinner

Mid-range

"Absolutely outstanding food, Our always go to place for deep dish, Just wonderful and we have to drive 25k to get here each way, so worth..."

Grumpy.geoffrey

"Great place, friendly staff, high cal food lol. But what do you want? It’s pizza pie with severalPounds of cheese and it’s heart attack..."

NorthernWolf

"Just came back from outstanding (and first time) visit to Chicago Style Pizza. I was served by the wonderful Grace and had the Eggplant Parmigiana; I..."

Meaghan Edwards

"My hubby and I have been going here for date night for over 25 years! The pizzas (Deep dish-stuffed or otherwise) are tasty and wonderful!!! The..."

Nancy Ashworth

"I've had this a few times. I like the deep dish pizza it is so delicious and filling. Soooo much cheese! On the down side it is so fattening and..."

Mick

"We got a 10-slice, 14-inch stuffed pizza with pepperoni and bacon (each topping cost an additional $1.75).When we finally got to eat our..."

Wanderlusting Mama

"Have ordered delivery/takeout many times and never been disappointed. My favorites is their tomatoe sauce with any pasta, subs Mediterranean salad,..."

Martha Case

"We had the Gnocchi which was tasty but nothing special, the bread we got was cold but our service warmed it up in the oven, made a huge difference...."

Felicia Lekhram

"Chicago Style Pizza is a hole in the wall restaurant tucked away in the midst of Hamilton. I rarely travel to Hamilton and I’m not too sure of..."

Food In The City Toronto

"Wonderful pizza! I introduced their roast beef pizza with green peppers to my friends and it was a smash hit. As I have never tried anything but..."

Dean Ritchie

"You know a place is good when people are lined up outside the door waiting for it to open. This place is very popular and the food is good. ..."

Orange2

"Was there last Sunday with a friend, food was great, service was great. Lasagna and ravioli was ordered with salads and the meals were wonderful..."

Kathryn Newell

"Great deep dish pizza , price point is on the $$ side but the taste and quality makes up for it. Dough and Sauce is good , quality of toppings is on..."

Adam

"This is the best and one of the only places serving real deep dish Chicago style pizza in Southwestern Ontario.Come here, eat deep dish..."

MoreFood

"Great deep dish! Have been going to Chicago the past 3 years and this is the only thing I could find that compares, really just as good. Going again..."

Rick Pinelli

"Always delicious pizza, both the deep dish and the regular. The battered mushrooms are delicious too. The pizza reheats really well, so it's..."

Christine Kinahan

"I've had delivery several times. Ordered almost everything on the menu. Food is always consistent. Large portions. Definitely recommend to..."

J Sarmiento

"My go to dish is the Veal Picante. The pasta has never been off. The sauce is flavourful but not enough to take away from the veal cutlet. Dine-in or..."

Phillie Bunts Softball

"Best Pizza in Hamilton. Never had a bad meal, in house or take out. Once you have their deep dish stuffed pizza you will not want to go back to..."

Drcavenstein

"Known for their deep dish. Very pricey though. Worth trying once but it is very rich and not worth the money I don't think Pasta is average I did say..."

Lifeisgood

"April 25, 2014 May 5, 2015 ~ rachelmf12 ~ Leave a comment Time for a quick n’ easy post! (while watching Hell’s Kitchen chefs make gourmet..."

Rachel Fish

"Yummy. Dinner for 2 - Vegetarian deep dish pizza. was so good. would recommend anyone that's in town to stop by this location. cheesy delicious . and..."

MooMoo

"Awesome. Unbelievably gooey Chicago style pizza. One of a kind. Watch out for sun-dried tomatoes though-too fierce. Stick to mushrooms. Desserts here..."

Facebook User

"Mobile review. I've had great experiences from Chicago Style! The pizza is definitely a little more expensive than some places, but you get what you..."

Hamilton Diner

"Best Pizza in the City!. This is the best pizza in the city. The standard pizza is great but the deep dish is as good as any we've had in Chicago..."

Goin Dutch

"Amazing delivery tonight. My wife surprised me with a supper from Chicago Style tonight. It's more expensive than most of the cheapo pizza places in..."

Alienlanes

"This place was great I always order take out and never get disapointed yes its a bit of a wait but its worth..."

Beatrice

"Know what you're getting into. Don't get me wrong, this place is amazing. I've been a few times and it's been delicious every time. The pizza is..."

Jess

"Outstanding deep dish pizza! Bring your appetite or you'll be bringing home..."

Stephan Davidson

"Stick with deep dish pizza. The deep dish pepperoni is the only food item i would recommend at this place. it is very..."

McDaddy

"Love this place. Best place ever! Blown away by the great food and..."

Teddyhello1010

"Cozey environment, friendly staff, and fresh ingredients in a deep dish Chicago style pizza. Epic win. I loved my experience and the pizza was..."

A.K Niazi

"Deep dish with Italian sausage, mushroom and onion. Amazing. Also, the Mediterranean salad is..."

D.M.N.

"Pizza was very filling fed 3 people for 2 meals which you can rarely get anywhere else. I don't recommend trying to eat in as the line up is huge but..."

Paul James

"At first I wasn't sure about Chicago style in Hamilton. But the pizza was..."

Ed Stret

"Pretty good. The food here is great, just wish they had a bigger dining..."

Jerry

"Amazing! After many reccomondations we finally tried it and.... Pizza will never be the same for us! Everything in the restaurant smelled delicious!..."

Stephanie

"One of the best. It doesn't matter what you have here everything is great omg just yummy form the garlic bread to lasanga ,meatball subs ,deep dish..."

Fester

"Nevermind the pizza.... The pizza is excellent, but expensive. No reservations, always a line, and stale bread (thankfully it's free and you can..."

World Taster

"The Best. I've been going there since 1977. I haven't been disappointed yet. Even when they accidentally gave away my order to someone else during..."

The Phantom

"Yum. Gotta say.....pretty damn..."

Zen Master

"Been going to CSPS for over 28 years now. Love this place. Chicago Style Deep Dish roast beef pizza is probably the most amazing pizza you'll ever..."

Tomas Roeder

"The pizza was very tasty and super filling! However be prepared to wait forever and pay too much ($35 for one pizza). They don't seem to be able to..."

Shalynn

"Great food... questionable service. The food at Chicago Style Pizza is fantastic, a little pricey and the wait is a little long for the stuffed crust..."

Chris Mifsud

"Lived around the corner for years, heard about it seen the tv show you gotta eat here so decided to finally try it, had the stuffed pizza pepperoni..."

Billy

"Simply..."

Christian

"Love the pizza!. I read that this place was number one on trip advisor and was in Hamilton so decided to check it out. They open after 430 so me and..."

Philip

"Bob dole is a fan of the tobacco business, bob dole likes your style, bob dole, bob dole ,bob dole, bob dole, bob dole, bob dole, bob..."

Foodh8ter72

"So Good. Holy shit, how does one not like this place? I must say that unless you're early you should expect a wait in the line-up, but even after..."

KP

"Better Get Here Early. I have been meaning to try this place for a while, but the last time we were here we only got here 15 minutes before they..."

Darryl T

"The deep dish pizza is to die for. Sliced meatballs in pizza is the best thing ever! This place is always slammed but there is good reason for it...."

Phoebe

"Like it?? LOVE IT!!!. Saw the reviews on line & tried it out last nightGreat pizza....great. Pasta was good too, and a lot of itsmall..."

Scott

"Stuffed Pizza is the BEST. The stuffed pizza is super Delicious. Tons of cheese and the best flavour. It's more expensive than the cheap places but..."

Petepot

"How Pizza SHOULD be Made!. I wish someone in the GTA would make a pizza that could compare with this place. I've made a number of visits from..."

Joe

"So Good. The pizza and pasta there are Delicious! Must..."

Danielle

"Good Italian Food!. Famlily restaurant that has much to offer in the way of italian fare! I decided to go with the roast beef pizza with hot peppers..."

Man V. Food Fan

"Wish we lived closer - we've loved the pies here for over a..."

The Professor

"Awesome pizza and the fried ravioli was great. Portions were great. Service was good as well. They also..."

Jim McFarland

"Love the pizza - hate the delivery.. We love the Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza - we have never been disappointed with this incredibly filling pizza...."

Sada

"Great pizza.. My girlfriend and I shared a pizza and it was terrific. I enjoyed the casual atmosphere and would be back again for..."

Bryan Edgeley

"Unreal pasta- loved the alfreado ! huge portions, great price. loved it, craving to go back..."

Kate M

"Very good. A great place to get pizza and to sit and eat. Chicago style pizza is the cheesiest pizza known to man. Its made like a pie made of cheese..."

Poutine91

"Great service. The pizza pie is delicious and super filling. You definitely get you moneys..."

Blake Holiday

"STuffed pizza was very good and extremely filling! The box weighed a ton when carrying it out of the restaurant. One piece felt like eating 3. A..."

Jackie G

"3.5 out of 5 Pizza is not bad. I looked at the Top 10 for Hamilton and felt like pizza tonight so I thought I would stop by. The outside is well..."

HungryCanadian

"It's just a great place for well..."

Bobby Jones

"The best stuffed pizza..."

Wayne Sheculski

"Fantastic stuffed deep dish pizza!! Loved this quaint place. Parking can be found on the cross street. Great service, even with a packed house..."

Carmine Ciriello

"Absolutely amazing authentic cuisine. The pizza is so good had the stuffed pizza "No Self Respect" and was in heaven. Also had deep fried ravioli and..."

Jeremy Dunn

"This iconic pizza place has to be on the top of your list for a visit. While I no longer live close, the drive is well worth it. Photos below are..."

Deanna Heaps

"THESE BAD BOYS ARE HUGE!!! The pizza tastes good, it’s very thick and generous with toppings. We went there early when they just opened, so I’m..."

Suzan Samivand (Suzi)

"Delicious! All I expected and more, every single bite was full of flavour. Tiramisu was also a great experience, definitely will be back as many..."

Jose Valencia

"One of the best pizza's I've ever had so far. Always a worth a drive from someone coming from Niagara. We always pizza order half and half flavors in..."

christine jf

"This is a really special spot! Great service and food, I highly recommend their classic deep dish pizza. Something that seems so simple is actually..."

Reset

There are 122 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Hamilton

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Dan Doherty

Diane McConnachie Johnson

Lisa Black

Vidis Vaiciunas

D Blair MacLeod

Carly Ellis-Buchelt

Linda Linda

Brad McFarlane

Valerie Monteith Parker

Annice Allatt

Jason Parkinson

Julie Hunter

Ken Wright

Romano Matt

Chad Hughes

John Prentice

Robert McCloy

Drew Ferguson

Karen Togmus

Nathan

Avi I

Laura I

Matthew Neville

Michele Dobbie

Paul Tang

Joe Domenico

Robert Alaimo

Jeff Gunnar

Kristian Reimer

Pamela Henley

Judson Carter

Robert Melvin

Mike Jones

N G

hugo matos

L Z

Dinner Dog

Princessadewole Adeola

Shaked Kerem

Jennifer Diamantino

Smith

Ahmed Hani

Charlie Rose

Ashley Nunes

Jose Castrejon

Darlene MacNeil

Christopher Hill

Rob Laking

Brittany Garrard-Amos

Max Sundquist

Cordelia May

Denise Shanley

Katie Hp

Elda Giardetti

Bryan Adlam

Annika Yardy

David Eccles

Nikole Bak

Ash Allsop

OpenSource Dev

kunal ahuja

Chris Tassone

Metta

Melanie Cunningham

Jeff Lambert

J S

Colin P Hoedt

Diane Tessier