Can somebody please explain to me what exactly is going on with Toronto weather? One day, it's like 20 and sunny, the next is raining, and then you get a day like Thursday when it actually snowed. I would venture to say that all Canadians need massive closets to accommodate the frequent shifts in climate. Regardless of the recent lows, I have had a massive hankering for BBQ. Luckily, Toronto has seen a huge rush of BBQ joints, something that people like me had always prayed for. I may almost be a dietitian and a Jew, but I do love my comfort food, and I do find ribs and pulled pork incredibly comforting (please-don't-tell). There had been quite a lot of chatter about a new spot, Stack, on Yonge at Lawrence, so I thought we would check it out on Friday night.
We arrived at 8 for our reservation to a jammed packed restaurant. There were quite a few parties waiting, and I could tell that there was a bit of stress and confusion about which parties were waiting and who to seat next. Regardless, the owner (Todd) was very apologetic for the 5 minute wait, and had us seated in the upstairs immediately. This place is pretty large. It has a big bar downstairs at the front, quite a bit of seating all the way to the kitchen in the back, and then an upper level with additional seating and a smaller bar as well. They did a really good job putting the place together. It reminded me of a sports bar meets corporate family restaurant. Definitely not my style, but it was comfortable none the less and I can appreciate that.
Service was incredibly friendly. Our server went above and beyond to make sure all of my questions were answered, and that drinks were refilled promptly. Just interacting with other servers/hostesses, I could tell that everyone was chosen for their personality and smiles. This would be a GREAT place to bring children for that reason alone. The only service issue was that our mains came before the appetizer I had ordered, a mistake that was promptly remedied with a complementary dessert, and many many apologies from the server and the owner (apparently they ran out of bechamel and had to make a new batch). And you know, the place has been open on 3 weeks and is absolutely slammed. I can definitely forgive such a small slip.
Speaking of the owner, Todd spent a lot of time chatting with us about his vision and business. Apparently, he owned a Shoeless Joes in Durham for a long time and decided he really wanted to open a restaurant with a "Diners, Drive ins and Dives" meets "Eat St" feel with the ultimate comfort food- BBQ. He spent a lot of time testing recipes in his own drive way at home, attracting a hell of a lot of attention from seduced neighbours. He also told us that he's looking into opening a Food Truck and even a second location somewhere in Durham region. Hope he knows he's got competition with Buster Rhinos so close.
Despite it's Southern influences in menu, Stack has a huge local focus. They source all of their meats, breads, ice cream etc from local companies, and Todd was adamant that he was really trying to get high quality ingredients and when possible, make everything from scratch.
So lets talk about what I ate/drank. The drink menu read a lot like a list of offerings at bat mitzfa, except that the drinks had booze in them. I will admit, I was super tempted by the insane alcoholic milkshake menu, but I knew that if I even attempted that, I would have no room for dessert, so I opted instead for their Strawberry Lime MMMojito with Jones Strawberry Lime soda with Light rum, simple syrup, ice, fresh mint, lime juice and strawberry garnish. It was pretty easy to drink, as the soda's sweetness really masked the booze. However, it did remind me a bit too much of a "cooler", and all of those unsavoury youth memories came rushing back. Probably better saved for the 19 year olds. For the rest of us, BBQ is best with beer, anyways.
I really would have liked to sample more of their BBQ items, but there was only two of us so we really had to choose. They do have a "Ultimate Platter" (with a full rack of ribs, quarter chicken, pulled pork, stack brisket, baked beans, mac and cheese, fries and mini buns) but even that would have been way too much for two. Todd, if you are reading this, please do a half portion of this platter!
Mac and Cheese with 3 Cheese Bechamel Sauce and Panko Bread Crust
A very good mac and cheese. It had a lot of creamy sauce as well as stringy cheese and a crumbly buttery crust on top. Texturally, this was a great mac and cheese. My only criticism is that it could have used a bit more seasoning as it was a little on the bland side.
Smmmoked Ribs with Memphis Mild Sauce
Just a heads up, its only the ribs and ultimate platter that come with sides (fries and beans). The other BBQ options are ordered a la carte, so we ordered a few extra sides to sample. The ribs were probably the disappointment of the night. The flavour of the pork itself was good, but I did find them pretty dry, and overly charred. While I appreciated that they weren't overtly fatty (no big pieces of fat), there was also very little meat on the bones. Hopefully it was just our rack.
Smokey Molasses Beans
I loved these. They had a nice hint of smoke, were perfectly sweet, and had lots of nice pieces of pork throughout. A must order side.
Fresh Cut Fries
Super crispy, nice cut, well seasoned. Another good choice.
Pulled Pork (with crispy onions and buttermilk dill) with Memphis Mild Sauce
Pork was tender, and the bun was perfectly fluffy and buttery. I actually didn't get any crispy onions or buttermilk dill (or at least I didn't detect them!) so I can't really speak to that element. I liked the mild sauce, but I did wish there was more of it, but that might be a personal preference. I do tend to like all of my PP tossed in sauce with lots of extra sauce on top (and here it was just applied on top), so I ordered a side of sauce to apply myself. Problem solved.
Slaw
Good, not great. Again texture was good, but it was missing something, either more salt, more sweet, more heat or more vinegar. Any one of these would have enhanced the flavour. I mixed in a little of that extra BBQ sauce and that made it much better.
Putters Kosher Pickles
Delicious crunchy, super juicy pickles. Can't imagine BBQ without them.
S'Mores Doughnuts (vanilla glaze with chocolate sauce, crumbled graham crackers and marshmallows)
If I were to adopt a really bad habit and feel really good about it, it would definitely be to drive to Stack on a weekly basis for my Doughnut fix. For a measly $5, you get the most ridiculously addictive treat that is so captivating that you're stomach pretty much forgets it is filled to the brim with pork, cheese and fries. Beneath a mountain of whipped cream you uncover about a dozen warm, freshly fried mini doughnuts (a la Tiny Toms style) that have been drizzled in a creamy chocolate sauce, tossed in a really satisfying mixture of buttery sugary graham cracker crumbs, sprinkled with mini marshmallows, and dusted with powdered sugar. The whole thing was unapologetically sweet, but in this case, it totally worked. By the time I had dug into the middle of the (seemingly neverending) cone, the doughnuts were completely encrusted with chocolate and crunchy, brown sugary crumbs, which despite my slight aversion to chocolate, was absolutely incredible. It was also pretty functional because all of those sticky toppings helped the marshmallows adhere so I had a perfect bite every time. The doughnuts themselves brought back so many incredibly memories of going to the Ex with my fam, but the extra toppings really took it over the edge. Todd told us he was inspired by the "Sugar Lips" food truck on Eat st (Food Network) and he's looking forward to creating seasonal doughnut specials (ie. fresh blueberries in the summer etc.). Todd, if you're reading this, please contact me if you would like a creative partner in designing these doughnut specials.
Alrighty, so for 1 coke, 1 cocktail, 1 app, 2 mains, and 4 additional sides, and a complementary dessert, our bill was $70 including tax and tip. Have you ever seen such a low number? Okay, so Burgers Priest was a "take-out" exception. But seriously folks. This was a pretty good meal for a super low price, and judging by Todd's keen interest in feedback and his commitment to his business, I'm confident they will continue to work out the small kinks and get even better. Looking forward to a repeat visit with lots of delicious doughnuts and maybe even a milkshake.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes