Review Fatty's Pizza - Thunder Bay

Daniel S

Was great pizza but took over an hour to deliver. Definitely recommend picking it up yourself. Update: went to pick up pizza tonight. The guy was super friendly and made a BOMB pizza, and made a custom pizza for my vegan friend with a full balsamic glaze. So good.

Tahmidul Islam

These guys are awesome! Open till 3.30 in the morning! Great pizza. Didn't get the pineapples I paid 1.50 for though, sad about that.

Chicka Lokita

I gave 4 stars because the pizza presentation was great and it tasted pretty good as well. My only issue was that some of the toppings were a little sparse in my opinion. Other then that I'm happy with both my food and the customer service :)

Lux T

I ordered a pizza and it came 40 mins later it was black underneath my fingers were going black it was cremated. Way to thin not even to mention the delivery man asked to buy weed at the door with the money for the pizza. Honestly I'd much rather any other place although the service was good the people were friendly. Pizza was not even edible it was hard and black to a crisp my dog didnt even want it. It looked nothing like the pictures showed. 25$ for cremated pizza y'all...

Sean Leveille

I ordered a perogi and a philly cheese steak pizza, smalls just to try. Super friendly staff and driver,they told me when pizzas would be here, and because they were busy, they called me back to let me know they would be a few more mins, which was fine, and then showed up promptly. But all that aside, the quality was through the roof, the pizzas looked picturesque, and were absolutely amazing. Super fresh ingredients and the cheese was out of this world. Price was normal for quality pizza. I would highly recommend this pizza to anyone who is a pizza connoisseur, it will not disappoint.

Crogan Tun

Reviews misleading... looks great... faster than promised (only place open)... polite delivery (called upon arrival)... everything accounted for and honest staff (was told of possible long wait and ingredient not available up front)... crust tastes homemade & toppings are quality/generous! glad I ignored the reviews! Good luck guys! I'm rooting local!

Megan Oja

Paid $42.00 for 2 ranch, a large pizza with extra cheese and 4 cans of pop I ordered sprite and got 7up lol what? I also did not get my ranch, or the extra cheese on my pizza there was barley any, it was also not the best service and delivery took a long time, not sure what I paid $42 dollars for... maybe I paid so much because it was the only place open but I won’t be buying from here again.

Jonathan Price

Got 2 pizzas last weekend! Couldn't believe the quality of the ingredients, Delivery came exactly when they said it would. The cheese though! Not sure what they use but it was AMAZING! would definitely recommend to try these guys.