Review Pizza Supreme - St. John's

The pizza spot you forgot existed. Slice was good, although the dough was bland for my taste. However, the staff member was outstanding and offered to cook an entirely new pizza since we were looking for just a slice. All in all a good experience, but nothing to write home about taste-wise.

A gem on the east end of Elizabeth Avenue! Ordered from here twice recently and the pizzas and garlic fingers were awesome! The sauce on the pizza was so good. Plentiful toppings and great dough. Great prices, delicious food and friendly, prompt and courteous service- what more do you want? Our new go to for take out pizza!

Best pizza in town, they use chicken pepperoni so you can actually enjoy a good stone baked pizza without "PORK", hence, the fact they have the best customer service in town!!! They stopped serving the chicken pepperoni

The sauce is very yummy along with the crust. Loads of different toppings to choose from. The pizza is cooked on an old stone oven which is very rare compared to now adays pizza places. Very delicious and always fresh!

Listen here boys and girls, if you're looking for a slice of pizza than by all means go to a place like pizza express or big bite, but if you're looking for the single greatest pizza experience of your life then you simply have to come here. The dough is created to perfection by the most talented pizza enthusiasts you could lay eyes on, I hesitate to even call it "service" because these employees treat me better than my own mother, and don't even get me started on the pizzeria, beautiful spacious area with such a comfortable feeling you'll want to stay there all day. Now let's talk about the main attraction. The only thing I would compare eating this pizza to is winning the lottery, and honestly I don't know which one I'd rather. After one bite of this pizza you will want to be a better person, I literally went out and started complimenting strangers because I didn't know such joy existed on this planet. I simply do not know the equation they must be using to create these pizzas but I can assure you it's got a crazy name like the "oh my goodness how is this possible it tastes so good" theorem. I refrain from using vulgar language, but the words to describe the deliciousness of this pizza have not been created yet. EAT THIS PIZZA AND YOU WILL DISCOVER HAPPINESS. Stay true supreme, stay true.

Was disappointed. Crust spread too thin for my preference and therefore over baked and dry. Same for the garlic fingers. Too thin and dry. Won't be returning.

I can honestly say this is the worst pizza I have ever had. It was so wet that when you would grab a piece the crust would tare off. It was uneatable. It takes a lot for me to not eat something i've ordered and I just had to let others know what they are spending their money on.

Great pizza, perfect for late nights, amazing family restaurant 10/10 would recommend