Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Sarnia

14 restaurant menus in Sarnia, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Milano's Pizzeria & Subs
Milano's Pizzeria & Subs
94/100 (217 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Shokas Pizza Company
Shokas Pizza Company
93/100 (1826 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Ifetachinni
Sit down
Pizza
Canadian
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Definitely rivals some of top pizza places in Sarnia! Great location and delicious pizza! Their gluten free pizza was also very good! Shokas is now..."
Jamie Kingswood
"I've always had there specialty pizzas, the Chicken as well as the Steak and they are both delicious!! We had friends from out of town so we got a..."
Hari Srinivasan
"This place is fantastic! It's definitely the #1 pizza joint in town. Had their pizza, and their pasta so far. Delicious. Will be trying their calzone..."
Krista Knoll
"Always great food and fun little atmosphere to eat in. Staff is very friendly and the owners always come talk to us and make sure everything is..."
Trevor Taylor
"Had that tomato and basil deep dish pizza tonight...it was wonderful guys! Thank you so much! As a vegetarian, it's so difficult for me to find pizza..."
Kris Luhponsay
"this place was amazing...first time trying was a 'what the hell' moment whilst doing laundry with my gf Caitlyn Essery....friendly service amazing..."
Tim DeBoer
"Totally impressed!! Last night I ordered a small Chicago deep dish and I have never enjoyed pizza so much in my life.. And one slice will fill you..."
Jennifer Knight
"Literally the best lasagna ever � My favourite place to get..."
Veronica Ayala
"Had a deep dish delivered. It arrived warm and it was heavy! It reminded me of a true chicago style deep dish pizza. Looking forward to getting..."
Ryan Farr
"Can't go wrong with the deep dish ! My new favourite..."
Justine Davies
"I just ate Shoka's for the first time tonight and it was phenomenal. Absolutely amazing pizza and I couldn't believe how much topping there was on..."
Lauren Crighton
"Excellent food and service. Owners were extremely friendly and nice. Will definitely return and recommend to..."
Jacob White
"I heard about this place from a friend who claimed it to be the best pizza ever.... I thought.. cmon... bold statement much!? I bought a pizza..."
Dahc Rekab
"Very delicious pizza! Eating on the road is often hit and miss but Shokas' is a definite hit in my book. If anyone wants a great pizza in a friendly..."
Sid Klooster
"Great place! The owner is great, the two young ladies working were great. The owner was very busy making meals but always takes the time to come out..."
Beckie LeNeve
"Great restaurant, ordered a small shokago deep-dish pizza, absolute must on a dine in more then enough food for 2 people!! Must go try! Generous..."
Tyler Couture
"We ordered a large shokas deep dish pizza and it was great! Plus nice..."
Sanghee Han
"Absolutely the best Italian food I have had in Sarnia. Everything was hot, homemade and sooo fresh! Pasta and sauce were delicious, as good as..."
Lisa Jacaruso
"Delicious salad and the BEST pizza !! Staff was also amazing. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a perfect crust with fresh..."
Diane Pratt
"Fantastic Pizza! Amazing Service! My First Experience Was Perfect! Finally got to come here since it opened and I'm extremely glad I did! Pizza was..."
Nick Gagliardi
"We just had an incredible meal from Shokas! We ordered the dinner for 4 of the chorizo tagliatelle, which also included bread sticks and garden..."
Ashley Foster
"The pizza is very good. The deep dish is excellent you would swear it was straight from Chicago. Big fan of the pasta dishes as well, the braised..."
Johnny L
Vago's Family Pizza
Vago's Family Pizza
93/100 (282 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Pizza
American
Italian
Pizza
Greek
Italian
Canadian
Greek
Canadian
Dinner
Lunch
Fast food
American
Greek
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Tried for the first time and it was delicious! Cooked perfectly and the pizza sauce has really great flavor. They aren't shy with the toppings! Wings..."
Nikki W
"Just had the best pizza from Vago's! It is now our new go to for pizza. Baked to perfection and with mega toppings! Delicious!! Try it next time..."
Anna R-P
"FAST! FRIENDLY! DELICIOUS!! Stop scrolling you found the spot in Vegos family pizza.. tried the for the first time last night, great pizza, great..."
denise king
"This family owned restaurant is amazing. All their food is made fresh and with love. Pizza is incredible and subs are the best you can find in town...."
Kelsey Guindon
"Update: Really enjoyed the pizza.. it had that authentic pizza oven aroma. I'm wondering how it would be with extra sauce as I usually do prefer..."
P H I L I P
"Amazing pizza and equally great service , couldn’t ask for a better establishment. Great work Vago’s..."
PROPHET LOC
"Pizza was pretty great! Lots of toppings but not over kill, good size. The owners even stayed there after their 9pm close time to let me come pick up..."
Nick Gagliardi
"Pizza was delicious! They put the perfect amount of cheese and loads of toppings ! This is my families new pizza place from now on !..."
Ky Knight
Giresi's Pizza Factory
Giresi's Pizza Factory
88/100 (2458 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Canadian
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
After-hours
Dinner
Salad
Wings
Cannoli
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
After-hours
Cheap Eats
"Without a doubt the best pizza in Sarnia. The ingredients are fresh. The delivery is hassle free. Ordering is easy... Not to sound like an old..."
Kevin Ryan
"Giresi's completes our Saturday nights every week! From the stringy gooey cheese to the perfectly browned crust, and from the time we order to the..."
Jody Wilcocks
"Big shout out to Giresi's Pizza Factory! We ordered 23 XL pizzas this past Saturday night. Excellent pizza. Would highly..."
Kelly Bond
"Not only do they have some of the best pizza I've had, but the entire Giresi's crew are some of the best people I..."
Stewart Wayne Fanning
"Hands down the best pizza in town! Great taste and great price. Always the go-to when ordering pizza..."
Brogan DesChenes
"I have loved Giresi 's Pizza since my first introduction back in the 70's in Reece's Corners!! Mr. and Mrs. Giresi had opened their doors to the..."
Nancy Charne Lucas Cable
"After finding out you guys had a vegan pizza, it made my day! Now I can enjoy your amazing pizza again! For being vegetarian and lactose intolerant,..."
Katherine Seppala
"awesome as always. a little biased as my son aaron works there. giresi family is amazing in and out of the pizza world. keep up the great..."
John Sawczuk
"The best pizza, awesome prices and even better customer..."
Jess Kramer
"Fantastic quality pizza. Friendly staff, great customer..."
Bill Dennis
"Absolutely bar none the best pizza in Sarnia, or anywhere close. Just had it again tonight and they nailed it. Keep up the amazing pizza..."
Joel Moor
"At work eating by far the best pizza in Sarnia ! Thank you ! Each and every time I have Pizza or The Sam Bits or Cini Bits I am in absolute HEAVEN..."
Steve Geroni
"They pizza is alwsys so good...the staff are very kind to me and bring my pizza out as I can't carry..."
Donanne Avery
"Ordered the Mediterranean, Pulled pork,and Chicken Supreme was an amazing experience. Thanks for making this the best 30th Birthday for my son and..."
Deb Hicks
"We ordered take out while on vacation and it was delicious. We got 3 XL pizzas and two orders of wings for 8 adults and it was a ton of food...."
Peter Vander Klippe
"We got 2 of the sweetheart specials for valentines day as it is a tradition for our family to get heart shaped pizza's for the kids from giresi's as..."
CRYSTAL Hennessey
"I had one of their special 12 Days of Christmas pies tonight and it was amazing! I love these creative specials they have been running and will..."
Karen Letts
"TASTY PIZZAS AND WHAT A GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE: I ordered two large specials yesterday from here and my order got mixed up. So I called them back..."
Gursahib Marjara
"We did a group amazing race style event for the River City Homeless Shelter and Giresi's Pizza Factory donated 18 pizzas for us all too enjoy after!..."
Bridget Gatschene
"New to the area I wanted to find some good pizza. After seeing the reviews I figured let’s try this place out. I was not disappointed. They..."
Who-V
"The best pizza in Sarnia Lambton. Prices are fantastic and the quality never falters. Always lots of toppings and unique flavours. They take pride in..."
Amanda Mayer
Italia Pizzeria
Italia Pizzeria
85/100 (1213 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Dinner
Lunch
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"By far the best and freshest pizza in town! Lots of other good pizza places in town but none compare to Italia’s! Always cook perfect, cheese,..."
LeoandTanya Dumoulin
"The puffio/panzerotti is great. It has so much cheese! They aren’t chintzy on the toppings and the crust is tasty. It’s a bit expensive, but I..."
Amy J
"The pizza here hasn't changed in decades the flavor is the same and definitely worth it they are always polite and courteous and no matter what you..."
crazy white nomad
"Hands down the BEST pizza in Sarnia. Fresh ingredients combined with fast and friendly..."
Jordan Kniaziew
"Best pizza...don't even challenge..."
Andrew Lister
Selina's South East Cafe
Selina's South East Cafe
84/100 (231 ratings)
Restaurants
American
International
Greek
Italian
Canadian
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
International
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Breakfast
Pad Thai
Curry
Sit down
Italian
American
International
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
Siccios
Siccios
84/100 (673 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Dinner
Lunch
Canadian
Pizza
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Best pizza in town. Love the..."
Cheryl Ann Wilkins
"I LOVE..."
Michelle Wadsworth
"Usually we get puffios but decided on trying the pizza and it was fantastic! They ran out of dips so they called and asked if we would prefer..."
Jessica W
"Delicious wings 🔥 great friendly ..."
Lore L
"The greatest puffios around, light, fluffy, and full of goodness. Everytime ! Only 25 min wait and very quick checkout from friendly staff. Great Job..."
Brent Lucas
"We ordered puffios and they were tasty! The staff was friendly and..."
Andrea Greer
Firenze's Pizza
Firenze's Pizza
84/100 (1439 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Canadian
Italian
Canadian
Dinner
After-hours
Sit down
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
After-hours
Dinner
Mid-range
"Best pizza you can have! Fresh, great toppings and unlike other places you actually get what you pay for. I personally have seen people drive hours..."
Ryan Mouzas
"If you grew up in Sarnia, you grew up seeing an elderly Italian lady making pizza in the Firenzes window shop with a cigarette hanging out of her..."
M. S.
"Incredible pizza point blank. I would recommend the 21 to really indulge in how great the pizza is from its crust to sauce to toppings. Will forever..."
Zay
"I go to Firenze's everytime I come back home to sign in. I have tried many pizzas and none have compared to the wonderfully consistent and delicious..."
You Do Go On
"Pizza was awesome! Definitely worth the..."
Jonathan Weeds
"This pizza is worth every dollar. So packed with ingredients. So much pepperoni and ham that you can't see the sauce. If you eat 3 slices you're..."
Salvatore Attinello
"1st went to Firenze's 30 years ago when I lived in Sarnia, at the time was the best pizza I'd ever tried. At the time there were 2 sweet older ladies..."
Marcus Stephenson
Napoli Pizza
Napoli Pizza
82/100 (554 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Canadian
Canadian
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Canadian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"This is the best pizza in sarnia...hands down... i stop in everytime i travel through purposely for the pizza... and thats often... cant fathom how..."
Walter Rosati
"Just had a fantastic pizza here..... And the panzarotti was excellent with my last visit. I will return..."
Greg Baltzer
"Ate here last night and it was fantastic! Service was top notch, food was even better! Our 5yr old said “this is the 2nd best meal I’ve ever..."
Sheena Day
"Sarnia has a ton of great pizza places.. Napoli happens to be one of its absolute best. I recently ordered one with Bacon, Olives, Mushrooms, and..."
P H I L I P
"As of today, we have a new favorite pizza place - Napoli. WOW! The pizza was absolutely delicious, with the best crust we have had in a very long..."
Marcia Weed
"Excellent pizza! Crispy crust, lots of toppings. Sauce has a nice tang. And I found the owners to be very friendly. We'll be..."
Rick Sands
"We happened on this restaurant by chance and will be back. It was an off night (something about hockey?) so we were on our own with both owners..."
kate montgomery
"Great pizza!!! You know it's good when you pick up a slice and the triangle doesn't flop! Definitely my go to pizza joint in sarnia..."
Cynthia DeLuke
"Very friendly and genuine family owned pizza place. Awesome pizza and pasta. Easily a top 2 pizza in sarnia. Would recommend to..."
Zay
"Joe & I ordered pizza + wings from here today for the first time + it is awesome! Pizza has a nice thin, crust with delicious toppings, + the..."
Debi Shortt
Cosmo's Tavern
Cosmo's Tavern
82/100 (611 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Canadian
Italian
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Lasagne
Pesto
Italian
Canadian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I have been going here since I was little. Favourite place for spaghetti and..."
Stephanie Aquilina Maness
Dante Club Hall
Dante Club Hall
80/100 (183 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Salad
Sit down
Canadian
Italian
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Buffet
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Reservations
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"Now with a great and very experience manager I see over the next year from 2022 to 2023 a significant change in the quality of food atmosphere and..."
XXX M1lk
"Recently went to a morning event there. The coffee was served about 45 minutes after it should have been. The event was half done when it came out...."
Jenna Herdman
Breadman Pizza Pasta Cafe
Breadman Pizza Pasta Cafe
78/100 (113 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
"My passion for pizza is unsurpassed and this is literally the best I've ever had. They have so many other great products, like breads, meats, cheeses..."
Sarah Veronica Swanstrom
"Such a great place. I recommend them to..."
Kayla Labelle
"Great food and customer service rocks � always stop in breadman for on go food or lunch..."
Dave Williams
"I have always loved breadman pizza ever since I was a kid. Still love it today . The brownies and canolli's are amazing as well. They also have ..."
Mel Lewis
"Great company, super food and food products! I picked up 3 balls of pizza dough on Monday, knowing we weren't going to be using them until today..."
John Klassen
"Bread Man makes some great pizza. My only complaint is they're not open late night. I remember being in grade school and getting Bread Man on 'pizza..."
Jennifer Perry
"Excellent authentic Italian cuisine. Very friendly staff and owners! They come out to make sure everything was good..... It's EXCELLENT!!! Their..."
Wayne Beast Stefura
East Side Mario's
East Side Mario's
77/100 (629 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
International
Italian
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
International
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Sit down
International
Canadian
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Steak and potatoes were awesome! Did not expect such good steak- my 2yo ate half of mine ! Staff was really great they cheered my girl up after a..."
Amanda Brittany
"Food was excellent! Considering how busy it was(extremely!) Service was also..."
Greg Brown
"great food and we had a great waiter named devon..."
Brittany Walker
"The food here is really good and the service is always super friendly. The hells kitchen chicken is really good if you like anything spicy or buffalo..."
Imortal Queen
"We had a late lunch/early dinner and had a fantastic experience! Our server, Brad, was great! Personable, pleasant, nice and always checked in with..."
Deb Beck
"Our experience last night dining at Sarnias east side marios was superb, from the friendly hostess to the happy server (Ron) we had a fun time. ..."
Jeff
"Thanks for having gluten free. My meal was amazing!!! And no problems later!!! Loved every..."
Dawn Asprey
Sicily Restaurant & Pizzeria
Sicily Restaurant & Pizzeria
75/100 (277 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Breakfast
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"What a great place this is. My sister and I were staying near by so thought we would try this out. The service was great, efficient and friendly. I..."
Eldin Mott
"The food is fantastic! I appreciate the time they take in making home made. I would really appreciate fresh mushrooms on the pizza versus canned, but..."
Krystle Kernick
"We have frequented this family owned and operated business for many years and have NEVER been disappointed with the food or service. The pricing is..."
Desiree Smith
"Best Italian restaurant in sarnia. Extensive menu and everything is made from scratch. Make sure you are hungry as the portions are huge. Our..."
Anna R-P