Review Prince Edward Pizza - Picton

I really wanted this pizza to be spectacular. I called and ordered a vegetarian. They said 20 minutes and it was ready in exactly 20 minutes! Score!The staff were working hard slinging pizzas and making poutines. I got my pizza and it was not cooked in the middle...neither on top or on the bottom. The dough was barely cooked and was a gooey doughy mess and the cheese was barely melted. I am not sure if the oven was acting up or if it was rushed. The staff were very nice. Maybe this was a one off. I would personally recommend you to ask for the pizza to be well done and it might help remedy this.

We love coming here each time we are in the area. Ordered 2 pizza slices and a pop for $6 each. The crust to sauce to toppings is well balanced. I really wanted to try the poutine but just can't pass on the pizza. Also, everyone is so friendly. I'm hoping they will open the dining area at some point.

We really enjoyed the pizza. They used lots of cheese and we didn’t even ask for extra cheese which is awesome in my opinion. The portion of the mushroom caps is good and they tasted good too. The pizza comes with a 2L bottle of pop. The reason we didn’t give 5 stars is because the only person wearing a mask was the cashier which during a pandemic everyone in an establishment is suppose to be wearing a mask. There were too many people not wearing a mask for it to just be a person with a health condition who can’t wear a mask. We are full now and the food was delicious so thank you. We would order again. Just a heads up to anyone ordering it’s Cash Only.

Great pizza! However it’s worth noting, none and I mean NONE of the staff wore gloves or masks while making anyone’s food while we were there. Friendly staff but considering the times that we’re in - this was disappointing and very concerning. 10/10 wouldn’t recommend this place anymore because none of the staff looked bothered by this despite the main gentleman who was making pizza to be super nice. Having to watch your food being made without a mask or gloves on isn’t appetizing folks. 😶

Best lunch slices of all time. Great value. Super friendly service!

I have to say this was the first time we tried this restaurant and it won’t be the last. The whole family loved the Pizza! It reminded me of my days growing up in Montreal. As this style of Pizza looks like and taste as delicious as Montreal style pizza!

Best pizza I've had in years! It was actually cooked unlike some pizzas with gooey dough in the middle... The thin crust had a nice crunch and the deluxe toppings were tasty! The pizza sauce could use a bit more garlic and umph, but otherwise, a great pizza that I would rate at 4.5. I'll be back next time I'm in Picton.

Not quite a 5 star but also not a 4 star. I think the 4.3 rating is accurate. The pizza was not as floppy as I normally like it but good amount of cheese and toppings. The crust had a good crunch to it. I also ordered a medium poutine which was very filling. If they used real cheese curds my rating would be higher.