Sluurpy
Reset

There are 13 restaurants

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Peterborough

There are 13 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Taso's
95/100 (849 ratings)
Restaurants
Mediterranean
Italian
Greek
Canadian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Greek
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Lasagne
Souvlaki
Panzerotti
Mediterranean
Italian
Greek
Pizza
Canadian
Delivery
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Street Parking
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Family style
Non-smoking restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
"Amazing quality! Excellent taste! The portions are more than enough and I am a big guy to boot! 1 pizza easily feeds 4 people! Can't wait to try..."
Paul
"My favourite restaurant, no contest. I wish I could justify making the 2hr drive weekly, because their food is absolutely worth it. And talk about..."
Mandi Adams
"Soooo good. All lasagnas hereinafter will be judged by Taso’s delicious lasagna. The chicken souvlaki was great too. We will enjoy leftovers..."
April Cornish
"FANTASTIC FOOD!!!!! I got the lasagna and it was by far the best one I have ever had! The portions are HUGE and the price is right! You can't go..."
Ryan L
"Staff were very kind and happy. The food was phenomenal! It was my boyfriend and my first time there and we were extremely pleased! Serving sizes are..."
EmberSpirit_99 ttv
"Amazing food, amazing staff. Peterborough is such a great place for all foodies..."
Jonathan Lumanlan
"Needed a reservation, but the atmosphere was great and the food, fantastic. Calamari appetizer...yum Calzone......"
B L
"This is a great place and the food is amazing! I had the lasagna last night and the thing was huge. It was absolutely delicious!!!! I looked around..."
Ryan Bayley
Amandala's Restaurant
93/100 (628200 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Canadian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Canadian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Duck
Salmon
Cheesecake
Escargot
Cheesecakes
Paella
Pesto
Pork
Canadian
Italian
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Reservations
Cash Only
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Full Bar
Digital Payments
Free Wifi
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Dinner
Mid-range
"This past Saturday night we were spoiled at amandalasptbo from the 1st moment we stepped in their doors to the moment we left. Upon entering we were..."
Larissa Nicole Nicholson
"Fashionably late but here goes! Deana and I want to thank Amanda and the entire staff for agreeing to host their first Wedding party and for doing an..."
Dave Robertson
"This truly is Peterborough's hidden gem. Delicious food, superb service, great ambiance and even the washroom is cute! Amandala's is our favourite..."
Lorraine Swift
"Valentine's day dinner was amazing. My husband and I had a great time and a great meal. He really enjoyed the alpaca meatballs and the chocolate..."
Kira Feilders
"Dined here on Saturday evening with my husband. Great service and setting with a delicious dinner and beautiful wine!!!Just awesome charcuterie, duck..."
Karen Mariani
"Amazing atmosphere. Candle lit table provides a romantic setting for your night out whether it be a gathering with friends or a special night out...."
Allie Rye
"Wonderful courteous staff, comfortable atmosphere, and dynamite cuisine! I'd give it 10 stars if it would let me. Simply the..."
Matt Witt
"Nice and cosy place, small menu, but the food is made with love. We can recommendate! Love from Amsterdam, the..."
Rob van Bogget
"Date night at Amandala's was wonderful! From Caesar salad to baked brie to chicken supreme and raspberry white chocolate cake everything was..."
Marilyn Cassidy
"Awesome food and service. A must dining experience in Peterborough. Our new..."
William Lee
"Amazing food and the best atmosphere in town! So much..."
Justin Holt
"Excellent! My friend and I came in for dinner this evening and very much enjoyed ourselves. Service was wonderful and food was..."
Sara Shadzik
"My hubby and I went to amandalas for our valentines dinner and it was amazing . Great service , kind staff as well as amazing food . Love how it's..."
Maggie Vanderbyl
"Awesome restaurant. Delicious food and great..."
Susan Kluthe
"What a delicious, flavorful and fresh dinner. I ordered the caesar salad as a starter, and the chicken supreme for my main. My husband ordered the..."
Afsana Tabibi
"Can't say enough good about Amandalas. Every table has real flowers. Started with three cheese and onion dip with naan bread. Bread was super soft..."
Amber Mowbray
"Amazing food, great service, and all around wonderful experience. Do yourself a favor and check this place out. We had appetizers, mains and dessert...."
Cory Wannamaker
"We went to Amandala' for our 26th anniversary. We are from Mississauga but were staying at a cottage a half a hour away and we found the place..."
Myra Policarpio
"Visited for a special occasion, the staff was genuinely warm and engaging. Quite frankly they were the perfect precursor for an amazing meal. The..."
Franklin Madison
"Amanda and her staff were fantastic! Very accommodating and friendly! Anya was great as was everyone else who helped make our event special! The food..."
Chelle B
"Spectacular service, quality food and lovely ambiance! My husband and I went there to celebrate his birthday and the staff were warm and welcoming...."
Marilyn Junkin
"Fantastic, friendly service!!! My meal was exceptional, we enjoyed a gorgonzola fondue for an appetizer ( best scallop I have ever had! ) and for our..."
dee roswell
Tre Ristorante Italiano
91/100 (910 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Mediterranean
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Meatballs
Lasagne
Carbonara
Sandwiches
"Sitting on the patio with my sweetie enjoying this outstanding delicious meal of mushroom ravioli. We tried to get a table without a reservation on a..."
Holly Russett
"Always a little reluctant to try new restaurants because I am Celiac. My Valentine convinced me to try this place because I love Italian Food and I..."
Dave Foster
"Absolutely amazing place to eat!!! I can't say enough. Our waiter Matt was great.... our food was delicious... I wish we lived closer so this could..."
Christy Woolvett Zruna
"Had an amazing meal last night with some girlfriends and great service. Highly..."
Emilie Hawthorne
"Our dinner on Valentines Day was excellent, I too had a chicken dish with fettucine noodles and they were light and oh so good, you can really tell..."
Toby Gail Arends
"This place is one-of-a-kind! We had an amazing lunch experience. The service is excellent and the food is the best. don't miss the chance to try..."
Cote Sanchez
"Delicious fresh authentic Italian food! Highly..."
Julie Moore-Pineo
"One of the best pasta dishes I have ever had and the bruschetta is out of this..."
Stevi Dulmage
"awesome bruschetta!! dinner was amazing, love going there, it was our 26th wedding..."
Laura Frost
"Totally recommended. Excellent service, food it's yummy. Great to have Martin as Chef there. We will go back..."
Magdalena Gonzalez Ruiz
"Best food I have had in peterborough puts many other restaurants to shame true good quality and freshest ingredients will recommend to..."
Shawn Borris
"It's a little new restaurant but it's the best Italian food I had be eating in Peterborough and I'm coming from a Italian family , you don't gonna..."
Alejandra Pontoni
"Super excellent service. Bruschetta was perfect. Had chicken parmigiana and fettuccine alfredo which were nice, but slightly overpriced. Saw some..."
Amber Mowbray
"Overall the food is cooked well and tasty. Portion is a bit small. I still couldn't believe they charge us for complimentary..."
mochaguy 22
"We came in on "April 29th 2017 at 7:30" to a amazing small Italian restaurant I had the Alfredo and my mom had the streak. For the appy we had the..."
Sam Krausert
"Went here after an impromptu stay at Peterborough. Restaurant was empty on a week night which was surprising as the food was fantastic. The decor was..."
Jennifer Perry
"The food was excellent, but the service was exceptional. My colleague has a garlic allergy, so we figured she would be stuck with only one or two..."
Meghan Iley
"My wife and I went in for dinner. It was our first time in and it was absolutely great. Real homemade pasta and sauce. The entire menu looked great..."
S.Andrew Smith
"What a delightful meal we had tonight. My wife enjoyed the Fettuccine Alfredo which was the correct portion for her. I had the Calamari Fritti as an..."
John Brook
"This is our favourite restaurant in Peterborough. The food is always perfectly fresh and home-made and so, so delicious. The staff is friendly. ..."
Meghan Dimmick
One Fine Food
84/100 (2306 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
European
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
European
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Focaccia
Pesto
Pork
Margherita Pizza
Pasta
Salad
Risotto
Meatballs
Ice Cream
Gelato
Sit down
Pizza
European
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Digital Payments
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Had a fantastic meal and experience last night at One Fine Food, so much so that I'm still thinking about it this morning! First things first, our..."
Krista Brailey
"My husband and I decided to try out the restaurant while on a day out together. We are from Peterborough and were excited to try out something new...."
Ceilidh Megan
"Went in for dinner several nights ago. My 3 year old LOVED her kids pizza - and she's picky about pizza! My husband and I shared apps and mains. ..."
Tania Coles
"I absolutely loved this restaurant. The food was super fresh and flavorful. They make everything in house and you can tell with the flavors. Our..."
Kerri Blair
"Amazing place for Peterborough. As much locally sourced as possible. Excellent wait staff. Explained everything. Kids loved the wood fired oven for..."
Alyson Kubica Martin
"Excellent lunch today. Delicious salad followed by a pizza with a spicy salami style meat and followed with a gelato & biscotti. Tuesday lunch hour..."
Ted Rundle
"In town for a hockey tournament and picked up some pizza to go. Pizza's were all amazing. Fresh ingredients and well made. Also grabbed some baked..."
Dan Allatt
"Still debating if it was the 2nd or the best meal I've ever had in Peterborough. Either way, the food blew me away. I got the chicken masala,..."
Adam Thomas
"Don't be shy!! Best wood oven pizza with a dough to write home about. Served on a plate with some amazing EVOO. Gelato house made that will keep you..."
John Theurer
"I entertained clients at the restaurant and was more than pleased. The service, knowledge of our waitress and her recommendation in choosing the wine..."
Kimberley Turney
"I have tried the pizza and the bagels and both are delicious! Highly recommend this place to..."
Lindsey Burkitt
"My husband I were there last night and both had the pizza! It was terrific! We didn't opt for starters as the pizza's look large. No room for dessert..."
Kathy O'Conor-Fenton
"Amazing! We are always looking for a new place to have lunch when we go to Peterborough. I checked on instagram under #peterborough and I saw photos..."
Anne Tidman-Hinchliffe
"Went to check out this place based on a recommendation. Bought Mocha, Prosciutto pizza, vanilla cheescake, raspberry chocolate mousse. Pizza was..."
Isuru Vidanalage
"Walked in during the outage to grab some wifi and ended up exploring the Whole Foods of the East. They have everything my little heart could desire..."
Ruxana S
"Delicious pizza & seafood pasta, very friendly service and nice environment. However, it was way too salty… Still giving 5 stars because other than..."
İlayda Ergul
"It was a pleasant first experience at the One Fine Food restaurant. We walked through the market and browsed some items they had. Lots of holiday..."
S. R.D
"Extremely high quality food, service, and seating. Every aspect of the food was top tier, I will be dreaming about it until the next time we can come..."
Brennan Payne
"One Fine Food offers a great premium dinning experience. We went as a group and they had tasteful pastas, wood fire pizza and steak. If you are..."
Patrick Smith
"Great Italian food restaurant. It was our first time there as a family and we will definitely be back. The food presentation was beautiful, the taste..."
Anna Marroquin
Jim's Pizzeria
79/100 (760 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Canadian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Lasagne
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"A very friendly lady took our order over the phone for delivery which didn't take long at all to arrive at our door by yet another friendly employee...."
GAM CAMECM
"My husband & I love this place.  We usually have the lunch special - half portion of baked lasagna with caesar salad.  Both are very tasty and the..."
Mel
"Best Pizza. Love ordering pizza from here- it always comes so quickly- fresh &..."
Sean Ouimette
"Best Traditional Pizza!. Easily the most consistent take out joint for the pepperoni standard. Other dishes are good but the pizza is the prime..."
Collin R
"I live in South Florida and we just said today how much we miss eating here! There is nothing like Canadian pizza an this is the best ever I wish I..."
Lily L
"Good old style pizzeria. Plain decor, pizza comes out on a silver platter. Big take out crowd. Love..."
Jeffrey Marchand
"Visited for a dinner on weekend. The hostess was kind enough to seat us immediately even though they were busy. We ordered their Alfredo pasta,..."
Siddhartha Palanki
"What’s not to like! The atmosphere is great inside and on the patio. You can tell the staff there are like family. Pizza is always delicious with..."
Nicholas Watts
"Really excellent pizza. They saved us during the big storm power outage. Pizza was hot and delivered fast. Really tasty. Also they didn't take..."
Oliver Plante
"Their pizza is really good, I would recommend extra sauce; totally worth the price. However, I can't say the same for the lasagna. It was very bland..."
Chad Horne
"Great food! Great customer..."
Christopher Wilson
"Food was excellent and as I waited outside in my car she actually brought my order out to me.. For what I ordered for myself there is enough for..."
PLynn
The Pizza Factory
78/100 (2111 ratings)
Restaurants
Asian
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Greek
Pizza
Canadian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Noodle
Pasta
Salad
Lasagne
Souvlaki
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Canadian
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We had lunch there today and even though we were disappointed that the buffett was gone, we had a fantastic lunch. The caesar salad was the best ever..."
Tammy Young
"Wonderful cozy place to be at. Had lunch and enjoyed our pizza, ribs, fries, and salad. Love that it's all made with extra love, time and care from..."
Honey Bunz
"We were in Peterborough for a hockey tournament and made a reservation for 40 people. The staff and service was excellent and they had The best..."
Dave Robins
"One of my favourite spits from college days.... Loved lasagna pizza....mmmm Absolutely love that they still make it for us inspite of it being no..."
Cheryl Mccullough
"Amazing! Best pizza I’ve ever had. Everyone needs to come to this place, you will not be disappointed. Service was great as..."
Alicia Gallant
"What can I say. Love it!!! I live in Calgary now, but whenever I get back to Peterborough, I always stop in. Best Pizza anywhere, nothing in Calgary..."
Ken Wood
"I have been going to the Pizza Factory since the 80's and I would definitely recommend it to anyone. Their Cesar salad is to die for. With a..."
Steven Godfrey
"We were beyond pleased with our food and the service! We’re here for a hockey tournament and when we asked locals where to eat, they said try..."
Cindy Van Empel-Popowich
"What a great place!!! Loved the old gas pumps and Coke machin. The food was out of this world. The staff is amazing. Also the washrooms and dinning..."
Jenn Elliott
"Love the pizza, the dough is phenomenal !! But the service is the real deal sealer!! Outstanding place to..."
Patrick McClean
"I just LOVE this place and we drive all the way from Cobourg to there just for..."
Andrew French
"Was there Tuesday afternoon Pizza and chicken wrap was awesome.. 1 staff girl was very..."
Conrad Mugford
"my husband an I went here for the 1st time not knowing what to expect couldn't believe the amount of food we got.My husband had the 2 piece fish and..."
Jean Turriff
"Awesome pizza, and salads. Service is always wonderful. You can really tell that the owner wants to keep his customers happy! Highly recommend the..."
Foodie
"This place has the best ceasar salad in town if you like garlic like we do. Very friendly staff. Great looking buffet. Food tasted great. Service was..."
GAM CAMECM
"First visit. Our daughter is attending school in Peterborough in the fall and we had to make a trip there this weekend. We arrived at dinnertime..."
The Urban Foodie
"Best Pizza. If you love garlic than their caesar salad is perfect! I get it everytime it is so good! And the Al Greco pizza is probably my favourite..."
Emilie
"Chicken n Ribs are great, but their specialty spagheti!..."
Nn Pogi
"Beautiful place. Very tasty meals, great atmosphere and a decent price! The all you can eat buffet is quality stuff, and your stomach doesn't regret..."
Sean Thompson
"Our server was super slow. Our food did come quick once we got a chance to order. She also forgot refills and bread for our table. Coffee came after..."
Christie Shepherd
"We had a great experience here and Sarah was a phenomenal server. We went with my brother who has autism and is non verbal. He rarely gets to sit..."
Nehal Siam
"Tried this place during a recent trip to Peterborough. There's a reason they're rated best Pizza in Peterborough! Great food, good service, good..."
Mista Jay
"When you ask google “what’s the best pizza in ____? “ you typically have high expectations. Pizza arrived quickly I was happy with that. For a..."
William Lapierre
"My first time here. Awesome food and very friendly..."
Edward Ratcliffe
"The Pizza Factory is probably our family's favourite restaurant in Peterborough. All of the food is amazing - especially the salads! The owner Peter..."
Ashley Doughty
"Seriously the best pizza my husband and I have had in a long time!! The garlic cheese bread was just as good and the fries as well!! It was super..."
jess Williams
East Side Mario's
72/100 (1553 ratings)
Restaurants
Canadian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
After-hours
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Lasagne
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Canadian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Lunch
Drinks
After-hours
Dinner
Mid-range
"So I decided to try a new dish, which ended up not agreeing with me. I told the owner I didn't like it, but it wasn't her fault. They took away my..."
Alexis Green
"A few year ago I had a bad experience at an Eastside Marios and refused to ever eat there again. This valentine weekend I reluctantly agreed to have..."
Debbie Finnie
"Love ESM peterborough from Owners to servers to bartenders to kitchen staff amd food if I could give it a 10 I would..excellent amd our usual food is..."
Carol Ann Phillips-Gordon
"The one time we ate there is was great and they even had crayons for my little..."
Amanda Lynn Melcher Dew
"It was great.will always go back Nice people work there made us fell at..."
Steve Oliver
"I Love Eastside Mario's. Their Chicken Tetrazini is to die for and the Bread of..."
Bev Hughes
"Love East Side Mario's my favourite place to..."
Colleen Robbins
"Love it! Pretty much the best staff anywhere, EVER. A real "family" feel...and not in the Mafia..."
Sheriff Taylor
"Visited this location for dinner on a weekday, it was pretty empty. We were seated promptly and our waitress was very good. The food was served very..."
Siddhartha Palanki
"All the stars go towards the service. The server was so attentive and friendly. The food is fine. Very much like heat and serve soup, and dressing..."
Veronica C
"We had an amazing experience at East Side Mario's. The food was really good and the service was excellent! I like the diversity of East Side Mario's..."
Hasan Sami Moudarres
"Had a great experience at this location, we had a little bit of a wait but the food was great and got a complimentary brownie for the wait that..."
Jenna Mullins
"Great place to go with kids and family. We enjoyed our food and drinks but thought the portions were a little on the smaller side and the prices a..."
Nigel Peters
"Went here for a team dinner after a basketball game. The restaurant itself is very comfy and has a nice feel to it. The service is fantastic and..."
Anthony Kostin