I've just had my fourth trip to Pepper Creek Pizza, and I have to say it is at the top of my pizza restaurant list. The crust has been perfect every time, and the sauces are among the best I've tasted anywhere. They definitely never scrimp on ingredients either.
First time out, I tried the Mega Meat pizza and it was without question the meatiest pizza I've ever had. That bad boy is thick with meat. That sounds so wrong, but it is very, very right. I also had garlic cheese fingers, which were amazing, and the donair sauce IMO is the best in town.
For my second visit, there was a bit of a glitch, and we wound up with something we didn't order, and we missed out on the extra donair sauce we had ordered, but what we got was still a damn good pizza and the garlic cheese fingers were as good as the first time, and they offered me a discount off my next pizza. Customer satisfaction: A+.
I wasn't sure I'd like a donair pizza, but I thought what the hell, so I went back a third time a few days later and blew my half-off discount on that. It's not my favourite, but definitely interesting, and very tasty with that really excellent donair sauce. I wouldn't hesitate to try it again.
I just sat down to a Hawaiian pizza, which has never been a favourite of mine, but this one truly exceeded my expectations. Nice big chunks of ham and plenty of cheese, that really sold it for me.
I may have trouble picking a favourite (or favourites), but I'm slowly working my way through the menu with that as a goal.
Update (9 September 2016):
I have had them all now, and every menu pizza is delicious!
Tonight I'm having the Greek, which is also not a traditional like of mine, but I had to do it just to complete the set (sans Veggie - I'll wager it's good if you like that sort of thing because the sauce on all these pizzas is on point). I'm enjoying it a lot, nice blend of the flavours and plenty of cheese.
I'll say my favourites are the Hawaiian (#2) and the grand prize goes to Mega Meat for being the deepest traditional style pizza I've ever had.
When I come back, I plan to heat it up with my own concoction of favourite spicy toppings. See you again soon!
First time having this terrific pizza. I ordered the chicken shawarma pizza, easily the best pizza I have eaten in years. The dough was soft, chewy and not greasy, the garlic sauce was fantastic and the chicken flavourful. Make sure you get a side of homemade donair sauce it’s a worthwhile addition.
Also wanted to mention the service was excellent. This is now my pizza of
Choice in Fredericton.
The pizza is definitely better than your big three pizza franchises. Service is very good. They are very good with delivery. Locally owned and operated. Check them out ...you never know they may become your new favorite.
This is by far the best pizza in Fredericton. Just a little mom and pop family own business. It’s small charm hides hidden gems as the food is beyond amazing. Large variety from slouvaki chicken kebabs tray with more then one can eat to Donairs, Subs etc… and of course amazing pizza. If you haven’t tried it yet, you owe it to yourself to give it a try. Cute little eat in or take out. You will not be disappointed
Rachel and Brad Waugh
Best pizza dough ever made in any pizza place ever. Remains soft and tasty foe hours after order until others. Good wings and always fast and postive talking to staff.
Absolutely wonderful! Can honestly say best pizza I've had in Fredericton. Homemade donair sauce is great too
I can't believe I haven't put a review for this place yet but here it is. There is no better pizza. I stand by that. They are the sweetest people with the best service, best food, best prices. You just can't compare. I was induced for labour in the hospital for days and this was the only thing I craved lol. Husband took me to get some and the owner told us he'd come up to the hospital with more whenever we wanted some. They're great people. 1000/10.
Went to pick up something in the area and decided to take some pizza home for supper. We were pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was, one of the best in the area. Too bad they are not closer to Oromocto, they would have a regular customer!
Best pizza in town, hands down. I have been in Fredericton for 5 years and eat out fairly frequently. I just discovered Pepper Creek today via Skipthedishes. Thank God, amazing pizza! Lots of cheese, generous amount of toppings. The garlic sauce is amazing! It tastes like the garlic sauce must be made in house. Highly recommend.
Absolutely love this place! I wish domino's pi$%#d me off sooner!! Best pizza ive had in the city and very friendly staff. Great quality and quantity of toppings, they don't skimp on the cheese, and the gimmick free crust is good on its own. Plus on the off chance you manage to leave some for tomorrow its almost as good cold or reheated as it was when they handed it to you!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes