I can't believe how many negative reviews there are about this place. Their pizza is amazing, one of the best in Victoria, and they aren't lying when they say TONS of cheese. Also the pasta is so good! I make the half hour drive to get this pizza regularly. 2 thumbs up!
Best pizza in town and worth the drive. I love the deep dish style and haven't found a pizza this loaded with toppings anywhere in Vic.
The only drawback is the price, but it's necessary. The pizza is great, easily one of my favourite pizza places in Victoria. However, if you're unfamiliar with how their pizza's are then the prices are amazingly high. But they need to be around that cost because of how thick they are and how loaded with toppings every pizza is. With that being said I do wish they would provide more specials throughout the year.
YUMMY!. If you love thick New York style pizza then this is the place for you! Lots of toppings and the best part is that they use 100% REAL CHEESE! And tons of it! Sometimes at lunch there is a bit of a line up but it moves fast. They charge a bit more then some other places but it's totally worth it....
The Hungry Traveller
+4.5
Great Pizza. I think I may have died and gone to pizza heaven.
Best Pizza Ever. If you like lots of toppings and BIG pizza's then you will love these guys. One thing for sure is don't get anything with sausages the meat the use for the sausage meat is just horrible tasting. Also if you don't have a huggeeeee stomach you might wanna go start small and try a medium pepperoni pizza. I will always keep coming back for more.
I work down the road and come by here a few times a week. Food is great and the coffee is always fresh. Emma the manager always makes an effort to check in and the rest of the staff are great. There is frequently new menu items being tested out and the addition of the dining room is being put to good use. Keep it up.
A timeless Victoria classic, this pizza delivers on both flavor and generous toppings, never skimping on the cheese. Recently ventured into trying their wings, and they too proved to be a delightful addition to the menu.
Friendly staff.. just don't like the type of pizza or the cost. Very heavy on the cheese, and the meat was extra thick. Nothing wrong with it, just not what I prefer. Also, $66 for 2 medium pizzas.. a Hawaiian and another 4 topping one.. would not choose this as my first choice.
The pizza is very good and reasonably priced. Gluten free pizza was great! What surprised me the most was their baked good section. Forget going to a bakery, this place has at all!! DELISH
We stopped in for dinner tonight, Keating pizza is well known for the best pizza in town. We ordered ahead of time, the pizza was waiting for us and still piping hot. We had the Keating combo, it was loaded with all fresh ingredients, lots of cheese and very tasty. It was pretty heavy and kept its heat for our picnic at Island view beach. The staff is very friendly and service was excellent. I noticed on the menu they serve breakfast! Might have to stop in here for breakfast one day.
I love this pizza. I can only handle it once a month or so but damn it's good local pizza.
Perfect lunch stop on bus trip to Butchart Gardens
Riding the 75 bus from the ferry terminal to Butchart Gardens, we decided to make a quick lunch stop on Keating Road. There were two other choices in the small strip mall, but we picked pizza over sub sandwich or taco options. The shop is clean and efficient, with counter service and a small dining area (most people we’re picking up take-out orders for lunch.) There are about 10 topping options on the menu board. My slice of chipotle chicken was excellent - thick, light crust, lots of cheese and sauce, excellent flavor with a touch of spice. Service was fast, but I couldn’t eat it all before we headed back to the bus stop in time to catch the next 75 ($5 all-day bus pass is the way to go!), so I wrapped it in foil and finished it while walking in to the ticket booth at the Gardens. Not from the area, but would definitely make it a regular stop if I was.
This pizza has been by far the best pizza place for many years.
One of my all-time favorites. This pizza is thick like they make it right and lots of cheese.
I've been going to Keaton's pizza since the late 90s. Feel free to ask them for a take and bake. You can take it home and cook it yourself and no work.
Heavy Duty Slices for Heavy Duty Hunger is an accurate summary. Fantastic tasting and very filling. Love the slice combos as well as their entire pizza menu. The staff are awesome! Did I mention the staff are awesome? They are truly awesome! Always smiling, always helpful and it is catching. Love the coffee too! And recently they added a pretty tasty donair to the menu with the choice of sweet sauce or the tzatziki sauce;-)
Last week (Friday). Walked up to the counter. I was greeted by Andre who took my order. He was extremely friendly, kind and patient. I ordered a medium poutine, a small meat lover and a medium pizza.
The food was fresh, tasty and the quality was perfect 🍕. I was very pleased with everything (+ the crust.. delicious).
I just wanted to say that we need more people like Andre serving Canada! Nothing better than walking into a place and feeling like home. You deserve a promotion.
Keating Pizza is one of the best on Vancouver Island. I highly recommend this place ❤️
Great Staff & Service
This is by far the best pizza in town
They cook with care the sauces are off the hook
Very good costumer service
If anyone had problem with this place they have poor mental health
love grabbing a slice on my lunch break great atmosphere
The price is right considering the size of one slice
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes