Review Sicilian Gourmet Pizza - Barrie

Dined in and the service was amazing! we had the baked cheese rigatoni and it was soo good!! Real authentic cooking, hot out of the oven and great portions! Definitely coming back!

ordered instore for take-out. tasty chicken wings, good linguine tetrazzini. giving 3 stars for giving me chicken quesadillas instead of beef that I ordered and sandwich has watery sauce, unsure if it was the thawed tomatoes or the washed lettuce? customer service was not the best. paid $70+ for an average dinner.

This place is so good. We came here randomly after seeing it here for years, and my god was it a hit. Amazing prices and the pizza is even better. The staff is friendly and inviting, the atmosphere is super unique. 5 stars all around. We’ve eaten more pizza here in the past week than anywhere else in the past year.

We stopped in because it was within walking distance from our hotel. It was SO good. We loved the small local feel and the food and service was amazing! Would recommend to anyone that loves a good pasta/pizza/wine!

What a gem of a place! Ordered a large order of pizza and wings for a group of people, first off, the food was delicious and steaming hot when I arrived for pick up. But more important than the taste, was the incredible service we received from the manager and all staff involved. Next time I am in Barrie, I will make a point of eating here again!

My husband and I are from Calabria. Every city we go to we try out Italian restaurants and bakeries, many call themselves Italian and they are not, you can tell by the sauce, ingredients, cheeses, bread and espresso. The Sicilian was the real Italian restaurants although the sports decor set us off a bit we thought it would be Bar style Italian. IT WAS THE REAL ITALIAN FOOD...1st sign was the sauce,natural no sugar, natural seasoning fresh tomatoes. The bread, real Italian crusty Bread.. There was much more, service was good, we were checked on and listened to. The menu extensive, pizza pastas and anything you crave in Italian food. Not upscale but food definitely Italian. We will be going again to try out the numerous other Italian dishes. Not a disappointment, did not expect real Italian, because many have the title Italian and are not, the sauce comes from cans. it must be tried out by anyone stopping into Barrie who loves Italian food. Cheers

I'm not sure how this place has such high reviews. We've ordered twice here. 1st time we had to return our order we picked up because the Nachos were a pile of absolute mush. It's like they took the bottom of the bag and dumped the crumbs on it and covered it in cheese. There wasn't 1 single whole chip intact. It was inedible, unless you like eating nachos with a spoon. 2nd time, we ordered pizza since that's what their known for. I was extremely sick the rest of the night throwing up, so was my partner. Glad to see others had great experiences but we will never dine here again.

A wonderful experience here at Sicilian Pizza...We placed our order and took a little drive and returned when they said to return. The food is extremely delicious and the service is excellent as well. A great choice of menu Items ...myself,I am a pizza fanatic ,being a pizza business owner as well...Try this place it's everything you expect to experience with a genuine Italian cuisine .